TY - JOUR
T1 - An Analysis of a Recent Criminal Trial Involving Sexual Misconduct with a Child, Alcohol Abuse and a Successful Sleepwalking Defence
T2 - Arguments supporting two proposed new forensic categories
AU - Schenck, Carlos H.
AU - Mahowald, Mark W.
PY - 1998
Y1 - 1998
N2 - The final judgment from a recent criminal trial in the British Columbia (Canada) Supreme Court is summarized and discussed. The trial involved sexual misconduct with a child, excessive alcohol use, and a successful 'sleepwalking (SW) defence' (non-insane automatism). Our comments on this trial provide an opportunity to present our arguments buttressing two newly proposed forensic categories: (i) parasomnia with continuing danger as a non-insane automatism, which originally was proposed for cases involving recurrent, sleep-related violence, but which can also be applied to SW cases involving sleep-related sexual misconduct and alcohol abuse (and other high-risk self-abusive behaviours); (ii) (intermittent) state-dependent continuing danger, an intermediate category within the 'continuing danger' concept, with the core feature being that a person acquitted of a criminal charge on the basis of the 'SW defence' (or some other parasomnia defence), in which the SW episode was provoked by a high-risk behaviour (e.g. alcohol intoxication) should bear full legal culpability for any future episode that was provoked by a recurrence of the high-risk behaviour - provided that the individual had wilfully engaged in that behaviour.
AB - The final judgment from a recent criminal trial in the British Columbia (Canada) Supreme Court is summarized and discussed. The trial involved sexual misconduct with a child, excessive alcohol use, and a successful 'sleepwalking (SW) defence' (non-insane automatism). Our comments on this trial provide an opportunity to present our arguments buttressing two newly proposed forensic categories: (i) parasomnia with continuing danger as a non-insane automatism, which originally was proposed for cases involving recurrent, sleep-related violence, but which can also be applied to SW cases involving sleep-related sexual misconduct and alcohol abuse (and other high-risk self-abusive behaviours); (ii) (intermittent) state-dependent continuing danger, an intermediate category within the 'continuing danger' concept, with the core feature being that a person acquitted of a criminal charge on the basis of the 'SW defence' (or some other parasomnia defence), in which the SW episode was provoked by a high-risk behaviour (e.g. alcohol intoxication) should bear full legal culpability for any future episode that was provoked by a recurrence of the high-risk behaviour - provided that the individual had wilfully engaged in that behaviour.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0032040806&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0032040806&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1177/002580249803800211
DO - 10.1177/002580249803800211
M3 - Article
C2 - 9604653
AN - SCOPUS:0032040806
SN - 0025-8024
VL - 38
SP - 147
EP - 152
JO - Medicine, Science and the Law
JF - Medicine, Science and the Law
IS - 2
ER -