TY - JOUR
T1 - Teaching and clinical efficiency
T2 - Competing demands
AU - Colletti, James E.
AU - Flottemesch, Thomas J.
AU - O'Connell, Tara
AU - Ankel, Felix K.
AU - Asplin, Brent R.
PY - 2012/5
Y1 - 2012/5
N2 - Introduction: Teaching ability and efficiency of clinical operations are important aspects of physician performance. In order to promote excellence in education and clinical efficiency, it would be important to determine physician qualities that contribute to both. We sought to evaluate the relationship between teaching performance and patient throughput times. Methods: The setting is an urban, academic emergency department with an annual census of 65,000 patient visits. Previous analysis of an 18-question emergency medicine faculty survey at this institution identified 5 prevailing domains of faculty instructional performance. The 5 statistically significant domains identified were: Competency and Professionalism, Commitment to Knowledge and Instruction, Inclusion and Interaction, Patient Focus, and Openness and Enthusiasm. We fit a multivariate, random effects model using each of the 5 instructional domains for emergency medicine faculty as independent predictors and throughput time (in minutes) as the continuous outcome. Faculty that were absent for any portion of the research period were excluded as were patient encounters without direct resident involvement. Results: Two of the 5 instructional domains were found to significantly correlate with a change in patient treatment times within both datasets. The greater a physician's Commitment to Knowledge and Instruction, the longer their throughput time, with each interval increase on the domain scale associated with a 7.38-minute increase in throughput time (90% confidence interval [CI]: 1.89 to 12.88 minutes). Conversely, increased Openness and Enthusiasm was associated with a 4.45-minute decrease in throughput (90% CI: -8.83 to -0.07 minutes). Conclusion: Some aspects of teaching aptitude are associated with increased throughput times (Openness and Enthusiasm), while others are associated with decreased throughput times (Commitment to Knowledge and Instruction). Our findings suggest that a tradeoff may exist between operational and instructional performance.
AB - Introduction: Teaching ability and efficiency of clinical operations are important aspects of physician performance. In order to promote excellence in education and clinical efficiency, it would be important to determine physician qualities that contribute to both. We sought to evaluate the relationship between teaching performance and patient throughput times. Methods: The setting is an urban, academic emergency department with an annual census of 65,000 patient visits. Previous analysis of an 18-question emergency medicine faculty survey at this institution identified 5 prevailing domains of faculty instructional performance. The 5 statistically significant domains identified were: Competency and Professionalism, Commitment to Knowledge and Instruction, Inclusion and Interaction, Patient Focus, and Openness and Enthusiasm. We fit a multivariate, random effects model using each of the 5 instructional domains for emergency medicine faculty as independent predictors and throughput time (in minutes) as the continuous outcome. Faculty that were absent for any portion of the research period were excluded as were patient encounters without direct resident involvement. Results: Two of the 5 instructional domains were found to significantly correlate with a change in patient treatment times within both datasets. The greater a physician's Commitment to Knowledge and Instruction, the longer their throughput time, with each interval increase on the domain scale associated with a 7.38-minute increase in throughput time (90% confidence interval [CI]: 1.89 to 12.88 minutes). Conversely, increased Openness and Enthusiasm was associated with a 4.45-minute decrease in throughput (90% CI: -8.83 to -0.07 minutes). Conclusion: Some aspects of teaching aptitude are associated with increased throughput times (Openness and Enthusiasm), while others are associated with decreased throughput times (Commitment to Knowledge and Instruction). Our findings suggest that a tradeoff may exist between operational and instructional performance.
KW - Instructional
KW - Patient flow
KW - Pay for performance
KW - Residency education
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84860629484&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84860629484&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.5811/westjem.2011.10.6642
DO - 10.5811/westjem.2011.10.6642
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84860629484
SN - 1936-900X
VL - 13
SP - 186
EP - 193
JO - Western Journal of Emergency Medicine
JF - Western Journal of Emergency Medicine
IS - 2
ER -